FANDOM


While this is called a tier list, and the magical girls, further referred to solely as girls, will be listed in tiers, the key aspect of each girl may be found in her given notes. It shouldn’t be blindly assumed that a random assortment of highly tiered girls is synonymous with the strongest available team for you.

Due to the sheer power difference between 5★ girls and the others, it may be assumed that any non-5★ girl not listed here belongs in the F-tier.

The girls listed here are ranked for mirrors, for questing/ pve the battle rules are completely different, allowing you to play slower games, where you take less damage, against a more "stupid" ai. In essence allowing magia users and healers to be used, something that may, and should, be considered suicidal in mirrors.

A girl with 3 disks of one type will be referred to as a "gorilla". Ie, Tart is a blast gorilla, due to having 3 blast disks

The order of the girls within each tier is arbitrary, and thus does not reflect any difference in power level within the tier.

Notes are described with - for negative note, + for positive note and ~ for average.

The Roles in a Team

These are the roles I will use to describe the functions a girl may, or should, be used to accomplish. The words used are similar to those used in other games, but might vary somewhat. Particularly the difference between a tank and an off-tank is different, due to how aggro (how the target is chosen by the ai) works in this game.

  • Dps. A girl whose build is meant to pump out as much damage as possible. High ATK is preferable.
  • Target. The girl the ai will target. This is in most cases synonymous with "the girl with the lowest DEF". Might have use for Damage Cut or Evade memoriae, but will often live at the mercy of your tank, if you field a tank, and in almost all cases be the first to die. Usually a dps. High HP is preferable.
  • Tank. A character who redirects attacks upon herself. Used to protect the other girls in her team. As of October 2018, a tank is synonymous with a girl carrying Assistant Instructor of the Ryuushin Style, The Sunlight That Shines Into the Complex and high DEF active memoriae. High DEF is preferable.
  • Off-tank. A character with a high DEF, preferably higher than the tank, who does not redirect attacks onto herself. The off-tank is the girl who is expected to survive the longest in your team, she should carry active memoriae giving her the most damage output once activated. High DEF is preferable. Mex4 can be used to make an otherwise not-tanky girl fulfil this role, given that the girl is not at the risk of being randomly hurt because of a blast on an ally.

Evaluation Guidelines

The girls are ranked based on the following guidelines:

  • The goal of a strong team is to gain as many points as possible, as defined by the rules in Ranked Mirrors, with the highest reliability.
    The current rules are:
    • The modifier starts at 1.5
    • Each turn after the first adds a -0.1 penalty to the modifier
    • Each connect, up to 3, adds a +0.1 bonus to the modifier
  • This makes the objective of any mirror team to win the game within 4 turns, where it gets as many connects of as possible.
  • The girls are assumed 4 slotted, max ranked, max levelled, and fully post-awakened (meaning they have their Final Items and Buffs all set of their Upgrade materials)
    • The girls are assumed to always equip proper memoriae, meaning they carry as many passives as possible, and that the memoriae they have equipped are fitting to their role in your team.
    • As a general rule of thumb, a girl may be considered 1 tier bellow what is shown here for each slot she is missing, apart from if they are only 1 slot, in which case they may be considered 4 tiers lower, due to the importance of 2 passives.
  • This tier list assumes the opponent you are facing are fielding girls with at least 50,000 points per girl, and that all those girls are properly equipped (ie. no inflated points due to usage of F-Tier, or otherwise useless, memoriae as defined in Memoria Tier List), as this is roughly the point where fielding your strongest available girls, without further tactics, starts not being good enough.
  • Due to the time limitation imposed by the high damage available in mirrors, magiae are, except where otherwise stated, assumed irrelevant to the girls ranking, as it will never affect the outcome of the battles.
  • Disks are preferred in the order of B > C > A, this becomes evident when inspecting Damage Calculation. An extract would be:
    • Blast disks have the highest possible damage output in a blast-puella combo.
    • Blast disks have the highest charge damage modifier.
    • A non-puella blast combo does more damage than charge-, accele-, or puella comboes.
    • In a puella combo accele, charge, and blast in the 3rd position all deals the same damage, but charge obviously set up for more damage by the following blast disk (charged accele damage is negligible and should be avoided)
    • In a non-puella accele does the most damage, but an AAA still only does roughly 5% more damage than ACB ( 1 + 1 + 1 = 3 vs 1 + 0.8 + 0.7 * 1.4 * 1.2 * 0.9 = 2.86), in the case of no blast up or charge up.
  • However, it should be noted that, no matter the damage available in blast disks, puella comboes are still highly preferred, due to the connect objectives in mirror matches, and puellas being the most reliable and simple way to get connects.
    • This implies that a girl's strength is positively proportional to how many blast disk she has, as this increases the amount of blasts available in a random disk draw.
  • Effects are evaluated based on their actual effectiveness. This means that while Here With You has Magia Damage Up [IX / 25%], ie effect IX, it is still strictly worse than My Bible which has Damage Increase [V / 25%] & Anti-Curse [100%], ie V. They have the same percent increase, but My Bible works on all attacks, including magia, while Here With You solely works on magia. (Using Memoriae for a simpler example).
  • Effects are evaluated based on their impact and limitations as described in Damage Calculation. This implies, amongst others, that Attack Up is superior to Damage Up at equal percent, and that Blast Up is somewhat harder to build around due to it's relatively low cap compared to its effectiveness.
  • Offensive connects are considered favourably to defensive ones due to the simple fact that if the enemies are all dead, there is no need for defense. Especially when coupled with active memoriae in later turns the game is often over, rendering defencive options useless in many situations.
  • Due to how the attribute wheel is laid out
    • If any attributeA in the trio of forest, fire and water proves to have below average strength, then the attributeB weak to that attributeA becomes stronger, due to having a lesser weakness, and the attributeC strong to that attributeA becomes weaker, as people will run less girls from attributeA, and more from attributeB which is strong versus attributeC. This is what we are seeing now, with forest and fire being generally weak attributes, and water having some very strong girls. The effect of this is that running fire is inadvisable, as you are almost guaranteed to face the low-risk-high-power water girls, and few forest girls. Running water is safe, and running forest is fine since it counters the popular water girls, without great risk due to few fires.
    • If you are running girl from the duo of dark and light, you want to kill the girls of the opposite attribute fast, as they will kill your girls equally fast. What this means is that you in most cases will want to run either dark or light, not both, so that you can more reliably, and faster remove the girls threatening you with your high damage versus them.
    • This makes it so the optimal combinations of attributes are either:
      • All girls from one of the attribute duo.
      • All girls from one of the attribute trio.
      • All girls from one of the attribute duo and one of the attribute trio.
      • All girls from two of the attribute trio, making one attribute your main attribute, and having one girl who is weak to your main attribute, so she can kill the girls strong versus your main attribute.


Some special notes on skill interactions

  • Evade is cancelled by any Status Ailment
  • Chance to Critical Hit does not stack, if recipient of two Critical Chance Up effects, the highest percentage is used. This makes Chance to Critical Hit memoriae and Chance to Critical Hit connects a bad combo.
  • Similarly evade does not stack
  • Evade does not work on counter, chase or similar effects.
  • A girl will not counter, provoke, guardian etc. if the girl cannot take any action due to stun, charm etc. However, there is currently a bug with Assistant Instructor of the Ryuushin Style allowing the carrier to still be able to provoke while affected, meaning that stunning, charming etc. a tank with Assistant Instructor of the Ryuushin Style is strictly bad, as she will be able to do her tank job, but at the same time not pollute the disk pool, allowing the AI to pull only disks from it's dps or off-tank characters.
  • A girl will not counter an attack she evaded.
  • The AI will assume no crits, no evades, no intervening from other girls through guardian etc. and no Damage Cut from the receiving girl when choosing targets, this means that any evade, guardian etc. will greatly increase your girls probability of surviving the round, and Damage Cut generally increases the chance for that girl. Damage negation abilities equipped memoriae are thus considered great due to their ability to keep the girl alive to the following turn, not only for the damage negated.
  • The AI will focus the target it expects to do the most damage on. This is usually synonymous with targeting the girl with the lowest DEF, except if it has type advantage, then the target will be a girl of the weak element.
  • Blast Up has a cap at +100%, implying that a carrier of Towards the Light! etc. will reach the cap and somewhat waste the effect if she is recipient of any Blast Up connect.
  • Chance to either leave the girl alive, or overkill (do a lot more damage than needed) is considered worse than barely, but consistently, finishing the girl. This means Crit, chance to Armour Pierce etc. is considered somewhat harshly compared to other effects.

The Two-Edged Sword of Stuns

The status aliments Stun, Charm and Bind will here be referred to as stuns.
This section will refer mostly to non-guaranteed stuns, but it must be noted that against Ultimate Madoka, every stun is non-guaranteed.
A stun might stun the enemy, leaving that character useless for the next turn, as well as removing evade, taunt (Except Assistant Instructor of the Ryuushin Style due to a bug) and guardian for that character. However, it might also give the enemy a free puella combo, possibly from the opponent's dps or off-tank , if the attack where your stun applied was taunted or guarded. The only time the stun effect will have a positive impact is if the character you bound has connect ready, you stun the opponents offensive character, or you stun the entire opponents team. Getting a stun , but not stunning everyone, when the opponent has two or three girls alive just guarantees a puella for the opponent, not great. In other cases the stun is simply un-impactful.

The One-Edged Sword of Blinds

The status aliments Fog, Dazzle and Darkness will here be referred to as blinds.
A blind might blind the enemy, removing evade from them, and adding a miss chance to their attacks. This is effectively the same as reducing the affected girl's damage with the likeliness of missing. Making Dazzle for instance reduce the expected damage from the affected girl by 50%. On top of this, as explained in Some special notes on skill interactions, the AI will not expect any misses, and as such will most likely allow their targets to live if they miss any attack, barring a crit.
Note that blinds stack multiplicatively, meaning that if a character is Fogged three times, their hit chance will be 1 * (1 - 0.25) * (1 - 0.25) * (1 - 0.25) = 42.2%.

Tiers

WORK IN PROGRESS. TIERS ARE ONLY APPROXIMATE THUS FAR

S-tier

Girl Notes
AttributeIcon Light TartTartTart
HP: 24,260 ATK: 8,976 DEF: 8,998
AcceleBlasthBlastvBlastvCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Defense Up [IX / 105%] &
Possibly the best magical girl in the game. The perfect example of an off-tank, Tart fields both fairly high ATK and DEF, as well as 3 blast disks, leaving her a superb finisher. Her connect is simple, granting the target both decent increase in damage and tankiness, allowing it to be used on both tanks and on dps without waste, but also has little else going for it
AttributeIcon Light Ultimate MadokaUltimate MadokaUltimate Madoka
HP: 29,143 ATK: 9,114 DEF: 7,906
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Damage Up [IX / 45%] & Status Ailment Resistance Up [100%] & Chance to Survive [HP restored = 20%, Chance to apply = 100%] & Remove Status Ailments [100%] &
EX Skill: Regenerate HP [All / II / 3%] & Status Ailment Resistance Up [All / II / 30%] &
Her mere presence renders memoria such as About to Leave in Haregi and Magical Halloween Theater significantly weaker, as well as many connects. Fielding high HP, fairly high ATK, and decent DEF, Ultimate Madoka can easily take the role of dps and target, as well as off-tank to a lesser extent. Her connect grants guaranteed Survive and Damage Up, which allows her to both save and enable her allies, which can, if used correctly, guarantee victory. Having 2 blast disks allows her to output significant damage if left for last, albeit less than that of the likes of Tart


A-tier

Girl Notes
AttributeIcon Flame Sakura KyoukoSakura KyoukoSakura Kyouko
HP: 22,580 ATK: 9,592 DEF: 7,268
AcceleBlasthBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Blast Damage Up [IX / 80%] & Damage Cut [IX / 70%] &
Blast gorilla glass cannon with amazing ATK and a good connect. If she wasn't Flame type, she'd probably be S. Even as is, she can put up a decent fight against water with her raw damage and pave the way for the rest of your team to come through once she dies.
AttributeIcon Dark Kure KirikaKure KirikaKure Kirika
HP: 29,248 ATK: 7,352 DEF: 9,432
AcceleBlastvBlastvChargeCharge
Connect: Chance to Counter [100%] & Chance to Provoke [100%] & Defense Up [VII / 90%] &
Probably the best tank in the game. Amazing bulk, great defensive connect, and the fact that she has two blasts means that she's less likely to interfere with the damage output of your other girls.
AttributeIcon Dark Riz HawkwoodRiz HawkwoodRiz Hawkwood
HP: 23,324 ATK: 9,580 DEF: 7,524
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlasthCharge
Connect: Chance to Defense Pierce [100%] & Chance to Critical Hit [IX / 70%] &
Very solid DPS character with enough defense to keep her alive. Can easily take down a Tart or Ultimate Madoka. Her connect is great, with guaranteed Defence Pierce and a high chance of a critical hit.
AttributeIcon Dark KazumiKazumiKazumi
HP: 22,958 ATK: 9,273 DEF: 7,458
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlasthCharge
Connect: Blast Damage Up [IX / 80%] & Chance to Defense Pierce [100%] &
Slightly worse than Riz, Kazumi is still powerful enough to earn herself an A rank. Has excellent damage output, good disks, and a great connect. The Blast Up in her connect is an enabler that will shine in a team with Blast gorillas.
AttributeIcon Aqua Shizumi KonohaShizumi KonohaShizumi Konoha
HP: 26,940 ATK: 8,388 DEF: 8,793
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlasthCharge
Connect: HP Restore [VIII / 47.5%] & Accele MP Gain Up [IX / 50%] & Attack Up [IX / 40%] &
Excellent stats with a fairly useful connect. Can fill most roles and do them quite well. Two blast disks give her nice damage potential.
AttributeIcon Dark Yukino KanaeYukino KanaeYukino Kanae
HP: 27,181 ATK: 8,358 DEF: 8,483
AcceleBlasthBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Attack Up [VIII / 37.5%] & Remove Debuffs [100%] &
A worse version of Tart, Kanae is still a force to be reckoned with. Her good stats, dark element and triple Blast makes her a powerhouse that can wreak havoc on the enemy team. Her connect's Remove Debuff is very situational and will probably not come into play much.
AttributeIcon Forest Alina GrayAlina GrayAlina Gray
HP: 22,370 ATK: 9,784 DEF: 7,106
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Attack Up [VIII / 37.5%] & Chance to Dazzle on Attack [100%] & Chance to Poison on Attack [100%] & Chance to Stun on Attack [35%] &
Alina's base stats are high, especially her ATK, making her well suited for being a dps. Having 2 blast disks she packs a fair punch, especially against water types. Her connect is, however, counter-intuitive. The Attack Up is in it self good, the poison is mostly inconsequential, and the dazzle is very strong, allowing Alina's connected target to half the expected damage of everyone she hits. However, the connect also has a low percent stun chance, which embodies the two-edged sword of stuns, which can, if it actually applies, render the dazzle effect useless, as the character that got dazzled won't be getting any disks to miss with anyways. Since the stun is a wildcard, the connect may not be used for defensive purposes (dazzling all enemies) without the chance-stun risks also taking effect
AttributeIcon Forest Holy MamiHoly MamiHoly Mami
HP: 21,708 ATK: 9,566 DEF: 7,669
AcceleBlasthBlastvChargeCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Damage Up Versus Enemies Affected With Status Ailments [IX / 45%] & Remove Status Ailments [100%] & Chance to Fog on Attack [50%] &
Very similar to Alina. Her stats are good, although more balanced, and her Fog connect is powerful even though it's not guaranteed, without the risk of Alina's stun.
AttributeIcon Light Kaname Madoka (Haregi ver.)Kaname Madoka (Haregi ver.)Kaname Madoka (Haregi ver.)
HP: 27,788 ATK: 8,298 DEF: 7,608
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: HP Restore [IX / 50%] & Damage Up [IX / 40%] &
Can perform decently in both offensive and defensive roles due to her stats. Her connect is situational - while the Attack Up will always be good, the HP Restore will often be wasted, especially since she herself will often be the target.
AttributeIcon Dark Momoe NagisaMomoe NagisaMomoe Nagisa
HP: 22,070 ATK: 9,534 DEF: 6,490
AcceleAcceleAcceleBlastvCharge
Connect: Attack Up [] & Chance to Fog on Attack [100%] & Chance to Anti-Evade [100%] &
Her personal memoria is what brings her to an A - passive Endure makes her incredibly dangerous. Without it, she drops to a B or even C. Since she's an Accele gorilla, she can pretty easily fire off her Magia if you let her. However, her Magia is slightly unreliable due to the random targeting. The effect is good though, and will usually hit all the members of a 2-3 girl enemy team.


B-tier

Girl Notes
AttributeIcon Aqua Nanami YachiyoNanami YachiyoNanami Yachiyo
HP: 23,479 ATK: 7,588 DEF: 8,316
AcceleBlasthBlasthBlasthCharge
Connect: Blast Damage Up [IX / 80%] & Chance to Critical Hit [IX / 70%] & HP Restore to Tamaki Iroha [25%] &
Solid Blast gorilla that can perform in offensive or defensive roles, although her stats aren't the greatest. Has an inconsistant but good connect. Extremely easy to slot and one of the best units for new or F2P players.
AttributeIcon Dark Isuzu RenIsuzu RenIsuzu Ren
HP: 21,420 ATK: 9,128 DEF: 6,844
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Chance to Chase [100%] & Chance to Evade [100%] & Attack Up [IX / 40%] &
A good glass cannon, she has high ATK even though the rest of her stats suck. Her connect is great if she survives to use it.
AttributeIcon Flame Mao HimikaMao HimikaMao Himika
HP: 30,227 ATK: 7,685 DEF: 9,305
AcceleBlastvBlastvChargeCharge
Connect: Endure [3 Turns] & Blast Damage Up [IX / 80%] &
Great tank with high stats and a good connect. Held back from being an A because of her Flame type - girls like Yachiyo, Rena, and Konoha will destroy her.
AttributeIcon Aqua Miki SayakaMiki SayakaMiki Sayaka
HP: 29,266 ATK: 7,595 DEF: 9,493
AcceleAcceleBlasthChargeCharge
Connect: Regenerate HP [IX / 3 Turns / 10%] & Attack Up [IX / 40%] &
Very high DEF and HP, average ATK, but lacking in blast disks, a very solid tank. The HP regen in her connect will almost never impact the game, but the Attack Up is simple and reliable damage, boosting her allies damage by a fair amount, despite usually not being able to connect with a blast disk
AttributeIcon Forest Aino MitoAino MitoAino Mito
HP: 27,141 ATK: 8,644 DEF: 8,471
AcceleAcceleBlastvChargeCharge
Connect: Chance to Evade [100%] & Chance to Provoke [IX / 70%] & Chance to Critical Hit [IX / 70%] &
Great stats that let her fill most roles, although her disks hold her back a bit. Really the only viable Forest tank, which allows her to be a nice damage sponge for water girls. Good connect, although it's a bit hard to use.
AttributeIcon Aqua Minami RenaMinami RenaMinami Rena
HP: 22,144 ATK: 9,776 DEF: 7,366
AcceleAcceleAcceleBlastvCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Accele MP Gain Up [IX / 50%] & Chance to Critical Hit [IX / 70%] &
Extremely high attack with a nice connect, her disks are the only thing holding her back. She's a very good glass cannon, but since she's an Accele gorilla she's somewhat harder to build around than someone like Alina or Ren.
AttributeIcon Light Izumi KanagiIzumi KanagiIzumi Kanagi
HP: 21,406 ATK: 9,695 DEF: 7,386
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Chance to Anti-Evade [100%] &
One of the stronger glass cannons in the game. Her connect is pretty good - the Attack Up is good, and while the Anti-Evade is niche it can easily make the difference between a win and a loss.
AttributeIcon Aqua Tamaki Iroha (Mizugi ver.)Tamaki Iroha (Mizugi ver.)Tamaki Iroha (Mizugi ver.)
HP: 28,648 ATK: 8,016 DEF: 7,932
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Blast Damage Up [X / 85%] & Defense Up [X / 112.5%] & Chance to Fog on Attack [100%] &
Decent all around, but not super good at anything in particular. Her connect leads her to be best suited to a team with Blast gorillas.


C-tier

Girl Notes
AttributeIcon Flame Rumor TsurunoRumor TsurunoRumor Tsuruno
HP: 21,568 ATK: 8,606 DEF: 6,999
AcceleAcceleBlastvBlastvCharge
Connect: Attack Up [VIII / 37.5%] & Chance to Charm on Attack [80%] &
Mediocre stats although she has a decent ATK. Her connect is good, but it's inconsistant and Ultimate Madoka renders it almost worthless. She's a decent filler attacker who's easily slotted if you rolled her once.
AttributeIcon Light Akemi Homura (Mizugi ver.)Akemi Homura (Mizugi ver.)Akemi Homura (Mizugi ver.)
HP: 22,660 ATK: 9,008 DEF: 6,627
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Chance to Evade [100%] & Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Chance to Skill Quicken [55%] &
She has a very good connect and high ATK, but her other stats hold her back. She can play a decent glass cannon if need be. Mechanically, she functions very similar to Isuzu Ren. However, Ren's magia is a little bit better as it helps protect her.
AttributeIcon Forest Tomoe MamiTomoe MamiTomoe Mami
HP: 20,941 ATK: 9,652 DEF: 6,553
AcceleAcceleBlasthChargeCharge
Connect: Damage Up [IX / 40%] & Chance to Bind on Attack [100%] & Chance to Burn on Attack [100%] &
Powerful connect with a guaranteed Bind and Burn as well as Damage Up. High ATK, low everything else. Having only one blast disk holds her back.
AttributeIcon Forest Sengoku NadekoSengoku NadekoSengoku Nadeko
HP: 21,870 ATK: 9,214 DEF: 6,906
AcceleAcceleBlastvChargeCharge
Connect: Damage Up [IX / 40%] & Chance to Burn [100%] & Chance to Charm [100%] &
Pretty much a reskin of Mami, except her connect has Charm and Attack Up instead of Bind and Damage Up and her stats are a little bit more balanced.
AttributeIcon Dark Mitsuki FeliciaMitsuki FeliciaMitsuki Felicia
HP: 21,087 ATK: 8,700 DEF: 6,530
AcceleBlasthBlastvChargeCharge
Connect: Damage Up [IX / 40%] & Chance to Anti-Counter [100%] &
Another mediocre glass cannon, she's a hard hitter but her stats just aren't as good, and her connect is simply average. Very easy to slot though, and is an accessible option for new and F2P players.
AttributeIcon Light Awane KokoroAwane KokoroAwane Kokoro
HP: 28,327 ATK: 7,308 DEF: 10,001
AcceleAcceleBlasthChargeCharge
Connect: Damage Cut [IX / 70%] & Chance to Counter [100%] &
Very high DEF, high HP and average ATK, but lacking in blast disks, fairly well fitted for being a tank. Her connect is very awkward, where the damage cut will allow her target to most likely survive, given that they start with a decent amount of HP, and counter the attacks taken. However, unless it is used on a full health off-tank, the amount of counters will usually be 1 or 2, given that Kokoro doesn't actually intercept any of the attacks directed at your connect target, which is unlikely. The result of all this is that her connect will, in most cases, be rendered useless, or close to useless. When you include the likeliness of not connecting with a blast disk, giving the connect target damage that way, it becomes evident that Kokoro will usually make any disk used by her a wasted disk

D-tier

Girl Notes
AttributeIcon Aqua Tokiwa NanakaTokiwa NanakaTokiwa Nanaka
HP: 20,743 ATK: 6,606 DEF: 6,479
AcceleBlastvBlastvBlastvCharge
Connect: Blast Damage Up [VII / 70%] & Attack Up [VII / 35%] &
The only non-5★ that's worth running, Nanaka will probably jump to an A rank upon uncap. She's a blast gorilla with an amazing connect, and is currently only held back by her 4★ stats. Makes a nice team with other blast gorillas.
AttributeIcon Flame Misono KarinMisono KarinMisono Karin
HP: 28,476 ATK: 7,874 DEF: 7,543
AcceleAcceleAcceleBlasthCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Chance to Dazzle on Attack [100%] & Chance to Magia Seal on Attack [35%] &
Great connect, but that's about it. Her stats are average, and although she's an Accele gorilla she probably won't get to Magia. Flame type also hurts her, as she dies to units like Konoha, Yachiyo, and Rena.
AttributeIcon Light Mikuni OrikoMikuni OrikoMikuni Oriko
HP: 20,088 ATK: 8,480 DEF: 6,480
AcceleAcceleBlasthChargeCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Accele MP Gain Up [VIII / 45%] & Chance to Critical Hit [VII / 60%] &
Very frail glass cannon. However, her single blast disk hinders her damage output. Her connect is strong, if she lives long enough to use it.
A solo Oriko is viable for Magia cheese strategy; even more so than the original Tsuruno one. Stick some MP Gain Up memoriae on her, and if she survives the first turn she can keep throwing out Magiae after that. The guaranteed Evade on it will help ensure she survives the remaining turns.
AttributeIcon Flame Togame MomokoTogame MomokoTogame Momoko
HP: 27,101 ATK: 8,428 DEF: 8,834
AcceleBlastvChargeChargeCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Charged Attack Damage Up [IX / 30%] & Chance to Defense Pierce [100%] &
Probablt the best Charge gorilla in the game, but that's not really saying much. Good connect with enough bulk to be a tank, but since she's Flame type she won't last long against the common Aqua girls.
AttributeIcon Flame Yui TsurunoYui TsurunoYui Tsuruno
HP: 18,927 ATK: 8,552 DEF: 6,056
AcceleAcceleBlastvBlastvCharge
Connect: Blast Damage Up [IX / 80%] & Attack Up [IX / 40%] &
Okay ATK with an insanely good connect, but the rest of her stats and Flame type make her insanely fragile as well.
A solo Tsuruno is viable for Magia cheese strategy; albeit not as well as Oriko. Stick some MP Gain Up memoriae on her, and if she survives the first turn she can keep throwing out Magiae after that. The guaranteed Evade on it will help ensure she survives the remaining turns.
AttributeIcon Dark Amane TsukuyoAmane TsukuyoAmane Tsukuyo
HP: 26,146 ATK: 8,708 DEF: 8,728
AcceleBlasthChargeChargeCharge
Connect: Charged Attack Damage Up [XI / 35%] & Chance to Critical Hit [IX / 70%] & Attack Up to Amane Tsukasa [V / 30%] &
Great stats, but she's subpar in every other regard. Her connect is chance based with a mediocre effect, she's got three charge discs, and she doesn't fit any role particularly well.


E-tier

Girl Notes
AttributeIcon Void Yakumo MitamaYakumo MitamaYakumo Mitama
HP: 29,120 ATK: 7,776 DEF: 8,460
AcceleAcceleAcceleBlasthCharge
Connect: HP Restore [IX / 50%] & Damage Up Versus Enemies Affected With Status Ailments [IX / 45%] & Defense Down [V / 15%] &
Can tank decently, especially for a magia team or a 5-girl team; her stats are pretty good. Not much else going for her - her connect and Magia both kinda suck.
AttributeIcon Forest Akino KaedeAkino KaedeAkino Kaede
HP: 20,511 ATK: 8,579 DEF: 6,352
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Damage Up [VIII / 37.5%] & MP Gain Up [VIII / 27.5%] & Regenerate HP [VI / 3 Turns / 7%] &
Low stats, mediocre connect. Doesn't really have much going for her besides being a good attacker into Water types and being easily slottable.
AttributeIcon Light Chiaki RikoChiaki RikoChiaki Riko
HP: 27,725 ATK: 8,175 DEF: 7,429
AcceleBlastvChargeChargeCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Charged Attack Damage Up [X / 32.5%] & Chance to Skill Seal on Attack [100%] &
Her stats are mediocre, but what really holds her back is her discs. Charge gorillas are generally subpar due to Charge's poor performance in mirrors(and elsewhere), and Riko is no exception. Her connect is mediocre - although the Attack Up is good, the Charged Attack Damage Up is mostly useless and the Skill Seal will almost never come into play since most magical girls won't live long enough to activate them.
AttributeIcon Aqua Kozue MayuKozue MayuKozue Mayu
HP: 21,629 ATK: 8,853 DEF: 7,023
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: Damage Up [IX / 40%] & MP Restore [VI / 25] & Accele MP Gain Up [V / 30%] &
Very fragile Magia type with a mediocre connect. Has a decent ATK stat and could be a workable glass cannon if slotted.

F-tier

Girl Notes
AttributeIcon Dark Akemi Homura (Megane ver.)Akemi Homura (Megane ver.)Akemi Homura (Megane ver.)
HP: 29,025 ATK: 7,554 DEF: 7,529
AcceleBlasthBlastvChargeCharge
Connect: Chance to Evade [100%] & Magia Damage Up [20%] & Magia Damage Up to Kaname Madoka, Miki Sayaka, Tomoe Mami, and Sakura Kyouko [7.5%] &
Having a high HP pool, but average ATK and DEF, Megane Homura is best at playing the target. Her disks allows her to participate in blast combos, even though this might not be smart since she is expected to die first, losing the connect. Her connect is only good for the evade chance, which again is not very reliable, since Evade ignoring memoria such as Magical Halloween Theater and Twin Shadows Sneaking Up are highly common
AttributeIcon Light Kaname MadokaKaname MadokaKaname Madoka
HP: 24,336 ATK: 6,832 DEF: 9,276
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: HP Restore [VIII / 47.5%] & MP Restore [VIII / 30] & MP Restore to Akemi Homura (Megane ver.) (only 5 ★) [II / 8] &
Having fairly high DEF, but average HP and abysmal ATK, Madoka may function as a tank, and little else. Her connect is rarely useful, only being useful on girls below half health, but then often having to give up a puella combo to heal. The heal percentage is no higher than what you may expect an opponent to do in 1 or 2 attacks, meaning that you used 3 low value Madoka attacks to gain an ability that might counteract 1 or 2 attacks, often at the cost of a puella, overall Madoka sets you up for more pain than she does your opponent, and should be avoided
AttributeIcon Dark Azusa MifuyuAzusa MifuyuAzusa Mifuyu
HP: 27,452 ATK: 7,933 DEF: 7,785
AcceleAcceleAcceleBlastvCharge
Connect: Accele MP Gain Up [IX / 50%] & Chance to Dazzle on Attack [100%] &
With decent HP, average DEF and average ATK, Mifuyu fits no roles particularly well. This is further emphasised by her connect, offering Dazzle and Accele Up, where only the dazzle actually does anything useful, and mostly defensively. On top of this she does not offer much damage to her connect target with her triple accele deck. She may be played in a tank-magia comp, but even there she falls short to both stronger accele users and better tanks
AttributeIcon Forest Miyako HinanoMiyako HinanoMiyako Hinano
HP: 25,030 ATK: 7,230 DEF: 7,100
AcceleBlasthBlastvChargeCharge
Connect: Damage Up [X / 42.5%] & Chance to Poison on Attack [100%] &
Pretty awful. Terrible stats, subpar connect, isn't very good at anything.

Un-tiered

Girl Notes
AttributeIcon Dark Makino IkumiMakino IkumiMakino Ikumi
HP: 23,632 ATK: 8,118 DEF: 8,015
AcceleAcceleBlasthBlastvCharge
Connect: HP Restore [IX / 50%] & Attack Up [VII / 35%] & Chance to Magia Seal on Attack [35%] &
Currently unranked due to being new and not yet tested enough. Probably around a C.
AttributeIcon Flame Amano SuzuneAmano SuzuneAmano Suzune
HP: 21,004 ATK: 9,513 DEF: 7,057
AcceleAcceleAcceleBlasthCharge
Connect: Damage Up [IX / 40%] & Chance to Critical Hit [IX / 70%] &
Opinions ranged from A-F and everywhere in between. Shelved for futher testing. Averaged out to about a C.
AttributeIcon Forest Holy AlinaHoly AlinaHoly Alina
HP: 23,541 ATK: 9,814 DEF: 6,942
AcceleBlasthBlastvBlastvCharge
Connect: Attack Up [IX / 40%] & Chance to Curse [100%] & Chance to Stun [50%] &
Amazing unit with insane attack and BBB spread(Forest's first gorilla). Brings down the water meta. Probably a high A.